Strategies for Using Insurance as an Investment Vehicle

Strategies for Using Insurance as an Investment Vehicle

Strategies for Using Insurance as an Investment Vehicle was written for Playlouder by John Reilly. John is a freelance content writer during the day and a bookworm at night with an extensive background in finance and investments. He also has a business degree and aims to educate people about financial literacy through his articles. Please note that contributing opinions are that of the author. They are not always in strict alignment with my own opinions. –Joe.

Using insurance as an investment vehicle is gaining traction among some Americans, with 23% of life insurance purchasers doing so to build cash value and save for retirement, according to a  NerdWallet study. However, it's essential to understand the benefits and drawbacks of this approach before diving in.

Insurance as an Investment Vehicle
Image Courtesy of Depositphotos

This article will explore various insurance investment options, how to evaluate your needs and goals, and strategies for maximizing returns on insurance investments.

Understanding Insurance Investment Options

Several insurance policies can be used as investment vehicles, with whole-life insurance being a popular choice. 

Whole life insurance policies include an investment component called cash value. A portion of your premium goes toward the cash value, which grows tax-deferred. This allows policyholders to withdraw or borrow against the funds to pay for expenses while alive, although doing so can reduce the policy's death benefit.

Insurance investments can offer more stability and tax advantages than other investments, such as stocks and bonds. However, they may also come with higher fees and lower returns, making weighing the pros and cons crucial.

Maximizing Returns on Insurance Investments

To maximize returns on insurance investments, consider the following strategies:

  1. Choose the right policy: Look for a policy with competitive returns, low fees, and a reputable insurer. Research different insurers and products to find the best fit for your needs.
  2. Manage cash value: Be strategic about using your policy's cash value. Withdrawing or borrowing against the cash value can reduce the death benefit, so consider other options before tapping into these funds. 
  3. Monitor and adjust: Regularly review your policy's performance and adjust your investment strategy as needed. This may involve reallocating the cash value or adjusting the premiums to align with your goals. 
  4. Minimize fees and expenses: Understand the fees associated with your insurance policy and take steps to minimize them. For example, opting for a no-load policy may help reduce the overall cost of your investment. Additionally, ensure you pay premiums on time to avoid a lapse in life insurance, which could result in losing the accumulated cash value.

Tax Implications of Insurance Investments

Insurance investments offer a range of tax benefits that can significantly impact an investor's overall financial plan. These benefits provide financial security for the policyholder and their beneficiaries and help manage tax consequences.

One of the primary tax benefits of insurance investments is tax-deferred growth, much like a 401k or IRA. This means that the cash value accumulated within a permanent life insurance policy, such as whole life or universal life, grows without being subject to taxes.

The interest earned on the cash value is applied to a higher amount, allowing the money to grow faster than it would if it were reduced by taxes each year. 

Tax-deferred growth can be an essential component of an investor's financial plan, as it allows them to build a substantial nest egg for their future without the burden of annual taxation.

Alternative Insurance Investment Products

Insurance products can serve as investment vehicles, providing financial protection and wealth accumulation opportunities. Universal life insurance, variable life insurance, and indexed universal life insurance are three popular options that offer unique features, benefits, and drawbacks.

Universal Life Insurance

Universal life insurance is a type of permanent life insurance that provides coverage for the insured person's life as long as premiums are paid and other policy requirements are met.

One of the main features of universal life insurance is its cash value component, which grows over time and can be borrowed against or withdrawn for various purposes. The cash value typically earns interest at a rate set by the insurance company, with some policies offering a guaranteed minimum rate of return.

Benefits of universal life insurance include flexible premiums, adjustable death benefits, and tax-deferred growth of the cash value. However, there are also disadvantages, such as higher premiums than term life insurance, potential surrender fees, lapse risk, and uncertain returns on the cash value.

Variable Life Insurance

Variable life insurance is another form of permanent life insurance that offers a death benefit and a cash value component. The key difference between variable life insurance and universal life insurance is the investment aspect of the cash value.

With variable life insurance, policyholders can invest the cash value in a variety of investment options, such as stocks, bonds, and mutual funds. This allows for potentially higher returns but also comes with increased risk due to market fluctuations.

The main advantages of variable life insurance include investment variety, potential for higher returns, and tax-deferred growth of the cash value. However, the drawbacks include higher premiums, investment risks, and management fees associated with the investment options.

Indexed Universal Life Insurance

Indexed universal life (IUL) insurance combines features of both universal life and variable life insurance. Like universal life insurance, IUL policies offer flexible premiums, adjustable death benefits, and a cash value component. 

However, the cash value growth in an IUL policy is tied to a stock market index, such as the S&P 500, allowing for potentially higher returns than traditional universal life insurance.

IUL policies offer several benefits, including greater upside potential, flexibility, and tax-free gains. Additionally, they provide permanent coverage as long as premiums are paid. 

However, there are also drawbacks, such as caps on returns, no guarantees on premium amounts or market returns, and the possibility of policy cancellation if premiums are not paid.

In terms of performance, alternative investments have seen an average annual return that ranges from 4.6% to 8.6% over the last decade, according to JPMorgan

As we move into 2023, investors and asset managers are expected to increase allocations to alternative investment strategies due to a market environment characterized by higher interest rates, low growth, and greater volatility.

In short, universal life insurance, variable life insurance, and indexed universal life insurance each offer unique features and benefits as investment vehicles. When considering these options, it is essential to weigh the potential returns, risks, and costs associated with each product. 

Consulting with an experienced life insurance agent or broker can help individuals determine which type of policy best aligns with their financial goals and risk tolerance.

Evaluating Your Needs and Goals

Before deciding to use insurance as an investment vehicle, evaluating your financial needs and goals is essential. Here are some tips to help you determine whether this strategy is right for you:

  1. Risk tolerance: Insurance investments tend to be less risky than stocks but may offer lower returns. Consider your risk tolerance and willingness to sacrifice potential gains for added stability.
  2. Time horizon: Whole life insurance policies are long-term investments, so ensure you're comfortable committing to a longer investment period.
  3. Liquidity: While you can access your policy's cash value, it may not be as liquid as other investments, like stocks or bonds.
  4. Diversification: Using insurance as an investment vehicle shouldn't be your only investment strategy. Ensure you have a well-diversified portfolio that includes other types of assets.


Using insurance as an investment vehicle can provide a stable, tax-advantaged way to build wealth for some individuals. However, it's essential to carefully evaluate the potential benefits and drawbacks before pursuing this strategy.

By understanding different insurance investment options, assessing your needs and goals, and employing strategies to maximize returns, you can make a more informed decision about whether insurance investments are right for you. 

Remember, a well-diversified portfolio is key to long-term financial success, and insurance investments should only be one piece of your overall investment strategy.